Skip to content 
Preserving Heritage: The Right Roof for Your Historic Home
The stakes are high when choosing the right roofing material for historic or older homes. Your roof isn’t just a barrier against the elements—it plays a vital role in preserving your home’s architectural character and historic charm.
At Blessed Roof, we specialize in historic home roofing. We understand the delicate balance between using modern roofing materials and respecting the traditions of historical materials. Whether anywhere in between, choosing the right roof can significantly improve your home’s curb appeal and structural longevity.
Why Roofing for Older Homes Requires Special Consideration
Unlike new builds, historic buildings often feature distinct rooflines like gable roofs and design elements like bay windows. These unique characteristics require restoration using traditional materials or appropriate modern alternatives.
Selecting the wrong roofing material can disrupt the aesthetic and violate local building codes or historical preservation guidelines. That’s why it’s essential to work with a contractor who specializes in historic roofing materials and understands the nuances of historic homeowners’ needs.
Is Your Historic Home Registered?
Since 1966, when the National Park Service created the National Register of Historic Places, they’ve helped historic home buyers preserve America’s archaeological history. They have helped protect over 90,000 historic properties listed; your home could also be one of them. Historic homes are living museums rich with stories, architectural style, and cultural significance from their previous residents. To be considered historical architecture, your home must:
Be at least 50 years old.
Have a connection to a significant event, person, or community.
Be of a particular architectural style.
Owning an older and historic home has its perks. However, there may be other restoration projects that prioritize your replaceable roofing.
Check With Your Local Historical Society
Before installing a new roof, consult your local building codes or historical societies. The Certified Local Government Commissions directory is a great place to start, offering location-specific guidelines that may dictate acceptable materials like wood shakes or tile roofs.
Planning a Roof Replacement or Restoration
Restoring or replacing a historic roof involves more than just choosing a material. Here’s how to approach the process:
- Hire an Experienced Historic Roofing Contractor
Historic home roofing isn’t a one-size-fits-all job. Choose professionals who understand preservation techniques and can work with materials like slate, wood, asphalt shingles, or tile roofs. At Blessed Roof, we bring decades of experience restoring the integrity of historical materials. - Get a Professional Roof Assessment
Inspections on historic homes require care. Professional roofers often use scaffolding rather than walking directly on the roof to avoid damage. A thorough inspection helps uncover leaks, structural weaknesses, and other underlying issues. You can schedule an assessment by visiting our Roof Replacement page. - Do Historical Research
Look for old photos, community records, or architectural drawings to determine what your original historical roof looked like. Research helps you choose traditional materials or accurate substitutes.
When planning a historic roof restoration, it’s essential to consider your home’s architectural style to ensure the new materials and design honor the past. Matching the roof style to what was originally used not only preserves the visual integrity of your home but also complies with many preservation guidelines. Whenever possible, aim to replicate or closely resemble the original roof, using materials that reflect the era and craftsmanship of the time. - Use Authentic or Compatible Materials
If original historic roofing materials are unavailable, choose modern products that mimic their look and function. For example, some asphalt shingles can replicate the appearance of wood shakes or slate. - Document the Process
Keep detailed records — from the materials used to the installation process — to preserve your home’s legacy for future generations.
Professionally Evaluating Older and Historic Homes
A professional evaluation of your home is necessary in most cases, so it’s paramount if you have an older and historic home. It’s essential to know your home’s age and historical circumstances. Older homes may be more complicated to renovate, so having an experienced roofing contractor will help determine the most appropriate materials for the job while maintaining the integrity and value of your home.
Best Roofing Materials for Historic Homes
Material choice is one of the most critical decisions when replacing or repairing a roof on an older home. Here’s a breakdown of the most common options:
Slate Roofing
- Ideal For: Georgian, Colonial, Victorian homes
- Why It Works: Slate is one of the most durable roofing materials, with a 75–100+ years lifespan. It’s fire-resistant and adds a timeless look to period homes.
- Considerations: It’s heavy, expensive, and requires professional installation and extra framing.
Wood Shingles
- Ideal For: Colonial Revival, Folk Victorian, Dutch Colonial
- Why It Works: Wood shingles (typically cedar, oak, or cypress) are historically accurate and regionally appropriate.
- Considerations: They have a life span of 25–30 years. In humid climates, they may be prone to rot and mold, and fire codes may restrict their use in some areas.
Clay or Concrete Tiles
- Ideal For: Spanish Revival, Mission, Mediterranean
- Why It Works: These tiles offer a historic look and superior performance in hot, dry climates. They can also help regulate indoor temperatures.
- Considerations: Heavier than other materials — may require structural reinforcements.
Metal Roofing
- Ideal For: Italianate, Federal, Farmhouses
- Why It Works: Long lifespan (40–75 years), low maintenance, and energy-efficient. Historically accurate when appropriately styled (e.g., copper, tin, or standing seam).
Considerations: Premium metals like copper are costly. Installation must allow for proper ventilation.
Matching Roofing Material to Architectural Style
Choosing a material that aligns with your home’s era is essential for authenticity. Here’s a quick style guide:
Home Style | Recommended Roofing Material |
Saltbox, Dutch Colonial | Wood shingles or shakes |
Georgian, Federal | Slate, wood shingles, or metal |
Greek Revival | Slate tiles |
Gothic Revival, Stick Style | Slate or decorative wood shingles |
Italianate, Second Empire | Metal or patterned slate |
Queen Anne/Victorian | Colored and patterned slate |
Spanish Colonial | Clay tiles |
Colonial Revival | Wood shingles |
Richardson Romanesque | Slate or wood (depending on roof type) |
Neoclassical | Slate or wood shingles |
Key Factors to Consider When Choosing a Roof
- Architectural Style: Match materials and design elements to your home’s original era.
- Climate & Weather: Metal and slate shed snow well; clay tiles perform best in heat.
- Budget: Slate and tile are long-term investments; wood and metal offer flexible prices.
- Local Regulations: Some historic districts have roofing restrictions — always check before starting.
- Maintenance: Consider how much upkeep your chosen material requires over time.
Maintenance and Longevity
Maintaining a historically appropriate roof is as important as choosing the right materials. Here’s how common materials compare:
- Slate: Over 100 years of life with minimal maintenance.
- Clay Tiles: 40–50 years, fire-resistant and weather-tough.
- Metal: 40–75 years, resists fire and pests.
- Wood Shingles: 25–30 years, but requires regular sealing and inspections.
Regular maintenance helps prevent minor issues from becoming costly repairs, especially on older homes. Learn more about roof longevity and maintenance on our Roof Replacement page.
Preserving the Past with Modern Protection
At Blessed Roof, we help historic homeowners upgrade without compromise. Whether replacing a failing existing roof or updating with modern roofing materials, we ensure compatibility with your home’s historic value. Don’t risk selecting the wrong roofing material—it could cost more than money—it could cost your home its legacy.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right roof for your historic home doesn’t have to be overwhelming. With careful planning, research, and expert guidance from Blessed Roof, you can preserve your home’s legacy while improving its protection and value.
Whether you’re looking for a historically accurate restoration or a practical upgrade that honors your home’s roots, we’re here to help. Learn more about our team on our About Us page or start your roofing journey by visiting our Roof Replacement page.
Let’s preserve the past while building a strong, lasting future.
